Menu

Humankind

Humankind

A Hopeful History

by Rutger Bregman

Rating 4.32 (73k+ ratings) Year 2019 Pages 462 pages

1. Human nature is fundamentally good, not evil

"Most people, deep down, are pretty decent."

The concept that civilization is merely a fragile mask covering inherent human brutality is not supported by empirical data. Observations of human behavior during crises and within daily interactions indicate that the primary instinct of most individuals is to provide assistance and work together rather than to succumb to chaos or selfishness.

From an evolutionary standpoint, the success of the human species is rooted in high levels of sociability. The "survival of the friendliest" suggests that traits such as empathy and mutual trust provided a competitive advantage. This evolutionary path resulted in physical and psychological changes that made humans more collaborative and socially perceptive than their biological ancestors.

A significant gap exists between actual human behavior and public perception. While media narratives frequently emphasize violence and self-interest, research suggests these portrayals are unrepresentative. The widespread belief that others are inherently selfish can lead to the creation of cynical social structures that inadvertently encourage the very negative behaviors they aim to suppress.

2. Cooperation, not competition, drove human evolution

"Humans are ultrasocial learning machines. We're born to learn, to bond and to play."

The primary biological advantage of humans is not individual cognitive power, but the ability to participate in social learning. This capacity for cultural transmission allows populations to pool knowledge and pass skills across generations, which has been the fundamental driver of the species' global presence.

Humanity underwent a process of self-domestication, similar to the evolution of domestic animals. Over time, humans became less aggressive and more cooperative, retaining more juvenile characteristics into adulthood. These changes facilitated the development of complex social structures and enhanced the ability to work in large groups.

In ancestral environments, the ability to establish and sustain social ties was a critical survival strategy. Individuals who excelled at building friendships and cooperating with others were more likely to thrive and pass on their genetic traits, cementing cooperation as a cornerstone of human development.

3. War and violence are not innate to human nature

"If we had been left to ourselves, there would never have been another shot fired."

Evidence from military history suggests a deep-seated psychological resistance to killing other humans. Analysis of various conflicts shows that many participants go to great lengths to avoid lethal action, often failing to fire their weapons or intentionally missing their targets when forced into combat.

Organized warfare is a relatively recent development in human history, appearing approximately 10,000 years ago alongside the rise of agriculture and permanent settlements. Prior to this period, human groups were largely egalitarian and lacked the structures necessary for sustained, large-scale violence.

Engaging in mass violence typically requires systemic efforts to dehumanize the opposition through propaganda. Because face-to-face harm is psychologically difficult for most people, modern military strategies often utilize distance and technology to bypass the natural human aversion to violence.

4. Civilization brought both progress and problems

"For ages civilisation was a disaster."

The transition to settled agricultural societies was a complex shift that offered technological growth but also introduced significant systemic issues. While populations expanded, this new way of life brought about several negative consequences:

  • The establishment of rigid social hierarchies and wealth inequality.
  • The emergence and rapid transmission of infectious diseases.
  • Long-term damage to the natural environment.
  • The development of organized, large-scale conflict.

The move away from hunter-gatherer lifestyles resulted in the loss of previously egalitarian social structures. As wealth could be accumulated and stored, power became concentrated, leading to more oppressive and unequal societies compared to the mobile groups of the past.

While the last few centuries have provided substantial improvements in global health and standards of living, these advancements have introduced modern difficulties. Contemporary society now faces challenges regarding environmental stability and a rise in various mental health concerns.

5. Contact and understanding can overcome prejudice

"Contact works. Not only that, few findings in the social sciences have this much evidence to back them up."

Social science research indicates that direct interaction between members of different groups is one of the most effective ways to diminish prejudice. This contact fosters empathy and breaks down preconceived biases, a phenomenon observed across various social and cultural divides.

The effectiveness of this interaction depends on specific conditions, particularly that the groups meet as equals and work toward shared objectives. Merely existing in the same geographic space is often insufficient; meaningful engagement is required to change underlying attitudes.

Leadership is a decisive factor in facilitating group reconciliation. By prioritizing cultural understanding and maintaining a commitment to core principles of equity, leaders can prevent escalation and guide divided populations toward peaceful coexistence and cooperation.

6. Power tends to corrupt, but it's not inevitable

"Power appears to work like an anaesthetic that makes you insensate to other people."

Acquiring power can cause measurable psychological shifts in individuals. Research suggests that those in positions of authority may experience a decline in empathy, a tendency to disregard social norms, and an inflated sense of confidence in their own perspectives.

The problem of corruption in leadership is two-fold: not only can power change an individual’s behavior, but individuals with lower levels of empathy are often more motivated to seek out high-status positions. This can lead to a cycle where institutional leadership is dominated by those least suited for it.

The negative effects of power can be countered through systemic checks and balances. By implementing strong accountability measures and encouraging leaders to practice humility and perspective-taking, organizations can reduce the risk of corruption and promote more ethical leadership.

7. Intrinsic motivation trumps extrinsic rewards

"If you treat employees as if they are responsible and reliable, they will be."

Management systems based on external incentives, such as bonuses or penalties, often fail to produce long-term results. For tasks requiring creativity or complexity, these "carrot-and-stick" methods can actually diminish internal drive and lead to lower overall performance.

According to self-determination theory, human motivation is most effective when three core psychological needs are addressed:

  • Autonomy: The ability to direct one's own actions.
  • Competence: The feeling of being skilled and effective in one's work.
  • Relatedness: The sense of belonging and connection to others.

Several organizational models demonstrate that trusting individuals with high levels of autonomy leads to success. Companies that minimize traditional hierarchies and empower self-managing teams often achieve superior outcomes compared to those using strict top-down control.

8. Play and freedom are essential for human development

"There's no guarantee they will. But they can."

There has been a notable decline in unstructured free play for children in modern environments, as time is increasingly diverted toward organized activities and digital media. This shift may negatively impact the development of essential social and emotional skills.

Engaging in unstructured play is vital for building several key competencies:

  • Problem-solving and creative thinking.
  • Emotional control and social interaction skills.
  • The ability to assess risk and coordinate movement.
  • A foundation for lifelong learning and internal motivation.

Innovative educational frameworks suggest that shifting toward student-led learning can be highly effective. By granting learners more agency and responsibility over their education, these models foster higher levels of engagement and better prepare individuals for the complexities of adult life.

9. Participatory systems bring out the best in people

"If you believe most people are rotten, you don't need to get worked up about injustice. The world is going to hell either way."

Highly centralized, top-down governance often results in apathy, stifled innovation, and systemic ethical failures. This dynamic is observable in both corporate management and public administration.

When individuals are given the opportunity to participate in meaningful decision-making, the results are generally positive. Participation increases personal investment in the outcome, encourages more diverse and effective problem-solving, and strengthens the overall level of trust within a community or organization.

Successful models of participation can be found in various sectors:

  • Local government initiatives where residents decide on budget allocations.
  • Business structures owned and operated by their employees.
  • Development projects driven by the communities they serve.
  • Collaborative digital environments where contributors share resources and knowledge.

10. Forgiveness and non-violence are powerful forces for change

"Hatred can be transformed into friendship and bitter foes can shake hands."

Analysis of social movements shows that non-violent strategies are statistically more effective than violent ones at achieving lasting change. Non-violence tends to garner wider public support and creates a more stable foundation for future democratic governance.

The practice of forgiveness is a practical tool for ending cycles of retribution. Institutional efforts that prioritize the acknowledgment of past grievances and provide a framework for moving forward have shown that it is possible to repair even the most fractured societies.

Approaching conflict through the lens of human psychology can be more productive than using physical force. Strategies that appeal to the emotions and humanity of opponents can successfully de-escalate tensions and resolve long-standing disputes more effectively than traditional combat.

Last updated: January 22, 2025

What's Humankind by Rutger Bregman about?

  • A New Human Narrative: Replaces the "selfish savage" myth with a portrait of humans as naturally cooperative and kind.
  • Fact-Checking History: Re-examines famous events and studies to prove that solidarity, not chaos, is our default response to crisis.
  • Societal Rebirth: Proposes that believing in human decency is the first step toward building more effective, trust-based institutions.

Why should I read Humankind by Rutger Bregman?

  • Antidote to Cynicism: Offers a research-backed defense against the modern belief that people are fundamentally bad.
  • Engaging Scholarship: Combines compelling storytelling with rigorous analysis of history, psychology, and biology.
  • Actionable Optimism: Demonstrates how a positive view of others can practically improve how we run businesses, schools, and governments.

What are the key takeaways of Humankind by Rutger Bregman?

  • Biological Decency: We are evolutionarily designed for friendliness and social bonding.
  • Context Over Character: Malicious behavior is usually a product of broken systems rather than inherent evil.
  • The Strength of Unity: Mutual aid is a more powerful survival mechanism than competition.

What are the best quotes from Humankind by Rutger Bregman and what do they mean?

  • “Man will become better when you show him what he is like.”: We live up to the image we hold of ourselves; seeing our goodness inspires us to manifest it.
  • “The mechanism that makes us the kindest species also makes us the cruelest species on the planet.”: Our deep loyalty to our "tribe" fosters love within the group but can lead to hostility toward outsiders.
  • “The real Lord of the Flies is a story of friendship and loyalty.”: Real-world accounts of stranded children show they prioritize cooperation over the fictional narrative of bloodthirsty chaos.

How does Humankind by Rutger Bregman challenge the veneer theory of civilization?

  • Debunking the "Thin Mask": Rejects the idea that laws and order are the only things stopping us from attacking one another.
  • Resilience in Disaster: Uses data from bombings and natural catastrophes to show that social ties actually strengthen when authority disappears.
  • Evidence of Altruism: Provides scientific proof that human instincts are geared toward helpfulness rather than predatory selfishness.

What psychological experiments are discussed in Humankind by Rutger Bregman?

  • The Milgram Shock Study: Argues that participants weren't "blindly" obedient but were manipulated into thinking they were helping science.
  • The Stanford Prison Experiment: Reveals the study was largely fraudulent, with guards being coached by researchers to act aggressively.
  • Robbers Cave Experiment: Shows that while researchers forced boys into conflict, the subjects' initial impulse was peaceful coexistence.

How does Humankind by Rutger Bregman address the concept of empathy?

  • The Empathy Trap: Notes that while empathy connects us, it can also act as a spotlight that blinds us to those outside our immediate circle.
  • Compassion Over Empathy: Advocates for rational, broad-based compassion which is more sustainable and fair than emotional empathy.
  • Skill-Based Kindness: Treats the ability to care for others as a muscle that can be strengthened to resist dehumanizing authority.

What role does power play in human behavior according to Humankind by Rutger Bregman?

  • The Corruption Effect: Cites evidence that gaining power can diminish the brain’s ability to mirror others, leading to a loss of empathy.
  • Hierarchical Distortion: Explains how vertical structures encourage people to prioritize pleasing superiors over helping peers.
  • Historical Abuse: Connects systemic cruelty to the way leaders manipulate human social instincts for destructive ends.

How does Humankind by Rutger Bregman relate to current societal issues?

  • Crisis Management: Suggests that modern global threats require a shift from "survival of the fittest" to radical collaboration.
  • Systemic Reform: Argues for redesigning democracy and justice systems around the assumption that people are trustworthy.
  • Cultural Healing: Encourages a shift away from media-driven fear toward a more realistic, hopeful engagement with our neighbors.

What evidence does Humankind by Rutger Bregman provide for its claims?

  • Untold History: Unearths forgotten stories of peace and cooperation that were ignored by mainstream historians.
  • Revised Psychology: Re-evaluates classic social experiments through a critical, modern lens to find the truth behind the data.
  • Evolutionary Biology: Points to "Self-Domestication," showing how humans evolved to be more like "puppies" than "wolves."

How does Humankind by Rutger Bregman propose we change our view of humanity?

  • Assume the Best: Recommends starting every interaction with the assumption of good intent.
  • Value Play and Trust: Advocates for environments—like schools and offices—that prioritize freedom and cooperation over surveillance.
  • Reject Toxic Cynicism: Views persistent negativity as a self-fulfilling prophecy that must be actively challenged by facts.

What is the Pygmalion Effect mentioned in Humankind by Rutger Bregman?

  • The Power of Expectation: A psychological phenomenon where people rise to meet the high standards set for them by others.
  • Educational Catalyst: Demonstrates that students perform significantly better when their teachers simply believe they are capable.
  • Organizational Philosophy: Suggests that treating employees as responsible adults creates a culture of high performance and integrity.